European Carbon Allowances: Summary of Market Characteristics and ICIS Price Forecasts
March 10, 2021 in Markets
A liquid alternative asset class with uncorrelated returns, a strong track record and further upside due to regulatory tailwinds
The EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) is the world’s largest cap and trade market, covering approximately 43% of the EU’s emissions. It covers energy-intensive industry, power and heat generation, as well as intra-EU flights. The regulator is currently reviewing an expansion of the scheme to include all transportation and heating, which would double its size.
European Emission Allowances (EUAs) are sold via government-run auctions on an almost daily basis. In addition, a liquid secondary market has developed, valued at €190bn in 2020, which much of the volume driven by the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE). On average, €860million is traded daily in the secondary market. The primary and secondary markets are in sync, with a 0.07% average price difference between auction settlement and the secondary market prices.1
EUAs represent an uncorrelated asset class, although more recently there is an increasing correlation with equities (YtD 0.51 correlated with MSCI World) as markets mature and attract more inflows from investors.
Selected correlations of daily returns over the last 3 years:
After the financial crisis in 2008/9, EUA prices plummeted and traded range-bound in the low single digits. In response, the regulator introduced two reforms, absorbing surplus from the market and installing a resilience mechanism called the “Market Stability Reserve”, which automatically manages the market balance by absorbing surplus allowances in case of external shocks.
With these reforms, and regulatory tailwinds resulting from a more ambitious carbon reduction target, EUA prices almost quadrupled from 2017-2020, posting annualised returns of >140%.2
EUA prices have proven volatile, with an annualised standard deviation of ~50% since 2013 and a 65% Sharpe Ratio over the last 3 years.3
Since the price forecast is less sensitive to emission changes (as the MSR balances larger effects), over the next decade, the main price driver will be how the supply of allowances is curbed, as per the following three scenarios:
- The MSR manages the market balance on a daily basis. Currently the regulator is considering i) increasing the rate at which surplus allowances are withdrawn and moved to the reserve and ii) lowering the threshold that constitutes as surplus
- The EU Green Deal requires more emissions abatement in the EU ETS, which would cut the volume of allowances handed out annually
- The additional cancellation of EUAs to address the mandated coal-fired power phase outs
All of these reforms would be bullish for EUA prices. The materialisation of such price rises hinges on the regulator implementing these changes, as well as the market “pricing in” future developments via investors who enter the market early.
1 2 3 ICIS: The EUA Market https://sparkchange.io/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/ICIS-Report.pdf
This communication has been provided to you for informational purposes only. This communication is not intended to constitute, and should not be construed as, investment advice, investment recommendations or investment research. This communication is not intended as and is not to be taken as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security or interest, nor does it constitute an offer or solicitation in any jurisdiction, including those in which such an offer or solicitation is not authorised or to any person to whom it is unlawful to make such a solicitation or offer. Distribution of information contained in this communication may be restricted by law. Persons receiving this communication should inform themselves about and observe any such restrictions. Any dissemination or other unauthorised use of this information or documents by any person or entity is strictly prohibited.
Spark Change Group Inc. believes the information in this communication to be correct at the date of issue. However, no representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy of any of the information provided. Some information in this communication is based on information given/obtained from independent research providers that Spark Change Group Inc. considers to be reliable. Analysis provided in this communication may be based on subjective assessments and assumptions and can use one among several alternative methodologies that produce diverse results. Hence, analysis and projections should not be seen as factual and should not be relied upon as accurate predictions of future events, performance, results or otherwise.